REVIEW: 30 Days of Night by Steve Niles and Ben Templesmith

30 Days of Night by Steve Niles and Ben Templesmith30 Days of Night, story by Steve Niles and illustrated by Ben Templesmith, published December 2004 by IDW Publishing. This graphic novel is a straight up horror story. You have a secluded town with more than 400 residents living in sub-zero weather where the sun doesn’t rise for 30 days. Welcome to Barrow, Alaska which turns out to be an ideal place for nocturnal predators that find the daylight intrusive and sees the town as a untapped food source.

The story opens with the last day of sunset. The sheriff and his wife are getting calls from all over town about some local thefts and a stranger in a bar causing mischief. It isn’t too long after the sun has set that the husband and wife team start to spot signs of trouble: a bonfire of cell phones are found in a pit and communications are down all over town. The stranger from the bar that they end up putting in jail proves to be something other than “human” and this leads to the beginning of the end for the town.

A meet is set up amongst the vampires who have congregated to Barrow, Alaska. The leader of the group has been summoned and things don’t turn out as planned. That was the biggest surprise of this entire novel. The town however ends up on the wrong side of a battle and the town folk are massacred. Well, not all of them. There are some survivors which includes the sheriff and his wife, hiding from the predators. Meanwhile, the story shifts to New Orleans where a shaman or voodoo priestess has someone intercept correspondence that exposes a suspicious meeting between two unidentified parties in Alaska. She seems to know what this meet entails so she sends her son with a camera to get footage of the planned event.

My thoughts: Last I’d checked, vampires were supposed to be scary. This graphic novel had a predictable storyline save one plot twist toward the end which didn’t make all that much sense to me and defies the story’s own logic. The artwork is pretty raw utilizing colors that emphasize the blood and facial structures and the freezing cold temperatures of the tundra. While the dialogue is clear, a few of the frames were a bit unclear. Furthermore, the story was a little bit of nothing for such a high price at $17.99 (paperback):

  • Not much in the way of complexity of plot
  • Lack of original plot line (but then how many different ways can you tell a vampire story)
  • Not much in the way of characterization
  • Raw artwork that looked pretty simplistic
  • Lack of logic continuity
  • Short, short, short story that left me feeling underwhelmed for my money

The part of the story that made me raise my eyebrows was when the sheriff, Eben, decides to save them all by turning into one of them. Now let’s go back, one of the survivors had been scratched by one of the vampires and was transformed. Immediately he started attacking the humans. Not so with Eben who managed to draw a sample of blood from the vampire and inject himself with it. Instead of attacking his wife or any of the other survivors, Eben is in control of his thoughts and blood lust and manages to kill the leader of the vampire clan and save the day- at a cost. This was not explained. Why was Eben’s response so different?

Then there’s the romance which was ok in a hokey kind of way. I guess that part of the story arc was supposed to engage the heart and it barely did that for lack of character development. I came away from this story not a fan and completely underwhelmed. What I did like was the atmosphere and the setting. I don’t get to visit Alaska often in my fiction reading (at one time I wanted to move there, too). All the talk of this graphic novel being “great” has led me to believe that if you think that something is great just because other people say it is then it is. It’s not. I was duped by the hype. There seems to be a motion picture in the works and more sequels on the shelf. All in all, it was an interesting visit to Barrow, Alaska but I think the one visit will have to be enough. My grade, C.

[tags]Vampires, Horror, Alaska, Steve Niles, Graphic Novel Review[/tags]


About Keishon

Voracious reader of just about everything.
This entry was posted in Book Reviews, Grade C Reviews, Graphic Novels and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to REVIEW: 30 Days of Night by Steve Niles and Ben Templesmith

  1. vanessa jaye says:

    Interesting and great review as always, Keishon. But I’ll admit that this was one of those times where you wonder if you’d read the same book as the other person. lol. Then I realized we hadn’t. I read the book/novel, you read the graphic novel. You’d think there wouldn’t be any difference between the two, but I *think* there was. Grant it my memory is a bit shady and it’s been over a year since I read the book, but I honestly didn’t find the book as lacking in plot/characterization as you found the graphic novel. In fact I think the issue you had the the blacked out part of this review was addressed in the book. I wrote my usual lame-ass reveiw here. Hmm… actuall that wasn’t much of a review as an initial impression based on the opening chapter, but I dont recall feeling let down by the finish. You do make me glad I didn’t check out the graphic novel after I’d read the book, though (as I was tempted to do).

  2. vanessa jaye says:

    Hey, Keishon am I in moderation? I wrote a reply that hasn’t shown up and I just don’t have the energy to recreate. The short version is, I read the book back in Aug 2006 and really enjoyed it. The problems you found in the graphic novel weren’t present (or at least not to the extent that they made an impression on me or ruined the book). Also the plot-twist issue you’ve blacked-out in your review, was addressed in the book so it was more acceptable. Having read this review I’m glad I resisted the temptation of reading the graphic novel months after I’d read the book.

  3. Avid Reader says:

    Hey Vanessa, my spam filter seems to love you. Sorry about that. I didn’t know that 30 Days of Night was based on a book. I’ll see if the library has a copy. I try to avoid novels and graphic novels that were adapted from another source. Like with I Am Legend, they’ve adapted that into graphic novel form from the novel. In that case, I’d prefer to read the novel.

  4. Avid Reader says:

    Now thinking back, the graphic novel didn’t explain the woman in New Orleans and her son and their role in the plot of the story.

  5. vanessa jaye says:

    I think the book is based on the graphic novel (or I should say ds, my-expert-in-residence on comics/graphic novels thinks so. heh). While I love Will Smith, I think part of the reason I haven’t been even tempted to see the movie is that I’m sure it won’t hold up to the book. :/

    Let me know what you think of the book compared to the graphic novel, if you do get around to reading it. It’s not a thick book if I recall, probably not even 300 pages and fast moving.

  6. jmc says:

    I read the novelization based on the movie. And then I read the graphic novel after seeing the movie. Lots of stuff was (of course) changed or left out of the movie, including the whole NO portion of the GN. But the movie made Eben’s “control” work a little bit better by creating a lag between infection and the blood urge. And it built into his character a caretaker mentality that made his choice work better (for me).

  7. vanessa jaye says:

    Boy this subscribe to comments works wonders. lol.

    It *sounds* like the movie took a page from the book (not the novelization). While, yeah, the delayed reaction was a little convenient for plotting purposes in the book it still worked in how they set it up. My memory may be murky, but I’d swear there might have been another delayed reaction previously, so the reaction was more of an unpredictable result, rather than always instantaneous. (I think I just talked myself in a circle trying to avoid spoilers. 😛 heh.)

  8. Avid Reader says:

    Well, you know what? I gave this GN to my sister. LOL. I’m done with it! And I’m easy, too – I just started reading comics so this is my first real disappointment with one. Sigh. Thanks ladies.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s