REVIEW: The Bronze Horseman by Paullina Simons

Standard

Bronze Horseman, The

The Bronze Horseman (2002) by Paullina Simons is one of those rare novels that leaves its mark on you.  It’s a  novel featuring a powerful lovestory set within a WWII backdrop. Captivating. Engrossing. Touching. Moving. Memorable. All adjectives that accurately describe one of the best fiction novels I’ve had the pleasure to read and recommend.
The story is thus:

Leningrad, 1941: The European war seems far away in this city of fallen grandeur, where splendid palaces and stately boulevards speak of a different age, when the city was known as St. Petersburg. Now two sisters, Tatiana and Dasha Metanov, live in a cramped apartment, sharing one room with their brother and parents. Such are the harsh realities of Stalin’s Russia, but when Hitler invades the country, the siege of its cities makes the previous severe conditions seem luxurious.

Against this backdrop of danger and uncertainty, Tatiana meets Alexander, an officer in the Red Army whose self-confidence sets him apart from most Russian men and helps to conceal a mysterious and troubled past.
Once the relentless winter and the German army’s blockade take hold of the city, the Metanovs are forced into ever more desperate measures to survive. With bombs falling and food becoming scarce, Tatiana and Alexander are drawn to each other in an impossible love that threatens to tear her family apart and reveal his dangerous secret — a secret as destructive as the war itself. Caught between two deadly forces, the lovers find themselves swept up in a tide of history at a turning point in the century that made the modern world.

Why do I love this story? I fell in love with Alexander Belov that’s why. His love and commitment to Tatiana during the War was completely inspiring and engrossing to me. Their first meeting is one of the best I’ve ever read. Alexander, in his army uniform, first spies Tatiana as she is eating her ice cream and waiting for her bus. Their eyes meet. A connection is made and a love is born between two people that you can’t help but cheer for and root for during the war. The story is set in Leningrad, Russia, 1941. When the story opens, Russia is on the brink of war. Tatiana’s character, to many readers, comes off as being a bit immature. Whimsical even. She seems unable to grasp the seriousness of her country entering war and the dire consequences thereof.

War comes and Tatiana and her family are left to survive. They depend on the help they get from Alexander when rations have made things a little tight. Alexander becomes a constant fixture in the Mentanov household. Why? Because after Alexander first introduces himself to Tatiana and follows her home,   she learns from her sister Dasha, that she is dating a Red Army officer who happens to be none other than Alexander. Tatiana is crushed a little. The situation quickly turns into a triangle of sorts as Alexander unsuccessfully tries to pursue Tatiana. Alexander is more than willing to break Dasha’s heart but Tatiana won’t have any of it. She loves her sister too much. Thus, the back and forth between Alexander, Dasha, and Alexander’s friend, Demetri gets interesting.

The war progresses for the worst; the food supply is cut off and starvation sets in for many parts of Russia. Tatiana and her family must get out of St. Petersberg and with Alexander’s help, that becomes their primary goal. The setting, the war, the characters—I was engrossed. I loved many things about this novel but notably the intimacy between Tatiana and Alexander took center stage. The author’s characterization is solid. She goes on to explain Alexander’s heritage; Explores Tatiana’s decision to live a life of lies to protect her sister that has consequences. The author has an excellent ear for dialogue. One of the best that I’ve read thus far. However, Ms. Simons subject matter in many of her novels tend to be rather depressing. This is one of the weaknesses of her writing: the subject matter.  I’ve tried to read Tully twice and haven’t completed it yet.

However, for those fans who have enjoyed The Bronze Horseman, you may not realize that there are currently three books that feature Tatiana and Alexander and they are The Bronze Horseman, Tatiana and Alexander and The Summer Garden. The last two novels were only available outside the US but I think that the latter is still only available outside the US (update all books are available digitally in the US). For some odd reason, Paullina Simons couldn’t publish a book here for lack of an audience. I love this book, however, The Bronze Horseman is not without it’s critics. For every book that you love there is one who hates it. Such is life.

If you’re interested in a love story set during the war, then you need to run out to your local bookstore and find this book. You won’t be disappointed. However, after finishing it, you will need to find the sequels in order to find closure. Consider yourself warned.

12 thoughts on “REVIEW: The Bronze Horseman by Paullina Simons

  1. Keishon: It was your love for this book – along with many others too – that convinced me to give it a try. It is a truly wonderful story isn’t it. I still need to see if I can get the third one here!

  2. I so wanted to enjoy this book. The setting and the plot were wonderful. But the hero and heroine? Meh. I didn’t hate the book, I just wasn’t totally wowwed by it. My library has TBH on the shelf, but not the second book. I haven’t felt inclined to seek out the next one to see what happened to Tatiana and Alexander, because I just didn’t care about them as characters. Is it worth the effort?

  3. Hi ladies,

    Well, jmc, the second book, Tatiana and Alexander, is told through the POV of the hero and much of the story from the previous book is basically retold, with added details of the war. We get much of the hero’s insight which I found helpful and interesting. Is it worth the effort? I frankly don’t know how to answer that for you. If you didn’t really care for the characters, then no. I found their story fascinating. I loved their love story. I don’t want to say more for fear of spoilers. Sorry this one didn’t work for you. Your not alone.
    What are some of your favorite romances? Just curious.

  4. I swear I left a comment on this post yesterday! The Summer Garden is now available in the US through bookclubs. Check out Doubleday or Book of the Month.

  5. Let’s see, my favorite romances. Off the top of my head: Persuasion (JA); When Venus Fell (Deborah Smith); Born in Fire (Nora Roberts); Bad for Each Other (Kate Hathaway); Welcome to Temptation (Jennifer Crusie); One Good Turn (Carla Kelly); Over the Edge (Suzanne Brockmann); Lucy Sullivan is Getting Married (Marian Keyes); Shattered Rainbows (Mary Jo Putney).

    Favorite books with a romance thread but which are not romances per se: M.M. Kaye’s The Far Pavilions; Megan Whalen Turner’s Eugenides books; Bujold’s Paladin of Souls; Pink Slip by Rita Ciresi; Roberta Gellis’ Madalene la Batarde mysteries.

    If I sat down with my reading journal and spreadsheet, the lists might change a little, and they’d definitely expand. I feel like I’m missing a major favorite, but I’m not sure which one.

  6. I love all of Paullina’s books. I read Tully when it first was published 12 years ago – it remained my favorite book up until The Bronze Horseman.
    I can’t see how anyone could not care about these characters.I had to RUSH out and get the 2nd book. The third also( I had to wait 3 mo for The Summer Garden, though)
    I don’t get into typical romance. I like drama- suspense and this had all three combined (as all of Paullina’s books do). I am glad to have found someone else who loves this story like I do.
    Give Tully another try. Also Paullina’s other books.

  7. Holly: I did read Red Leaves and that was a very good suspense novel. I will give Tully another try. Thanks for the encouragement!

    JMC: Hmmm. I haven’t read all your favs but I do agree with you on the Jennifer Crusie title! I’ll have to check out the M.M. Kaye books. I have one or two of them, somewhere around here. Thanks for your list.

    Marg: your one in a million, thanks :-)

  8. If you liked Red Leaves, then you might be interested to know that Spencer from Red Leaves is one of the main characters in The Girl in Times Square.

    Am I gushing too much?

  9. [quote comment="3195"]If you liked Red Leaves, then you might be interested to know that Spencer from Red Leaves is one of the main characters in The Girl in Times Square.

    Am I gushing too much?[/quote]

    I have The Girl in Times Square sitting on my bookshelf. A very nice reader donated it to me and other readers in the US when it wasn’t available here. Is it still not available here? I don’t know but, right now, I have to find the third Tatiana and Alexander book as I’ve misplaced it somewhere. On my next day off, I’m going into search mode.

  10. Pingback: Daily Deals: A dominatrix, a rock star, and an epic Russian romance

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s